Wednesday, October 10, 2018

Movie Reaction: Venom

Formula: Spider-Man * Upgrade

I must begin this the way I begin nearly every post about a $100 million movie: with the MCU. Sony has been the studio most affected by the MCU for the negative. WB has succeeded with some shortsighted attempts at their own DC interconnected universe. Fox has been content with all the characters they own as part of the X-Men universe. Paramount is more concerned with just staying afloat. Universal has dipped its toes into expanded universes with the failed Dark Universe and some monster movies with planned crossovers. Sony was king a decade ago. They have the Spider-Man rights: Marvel's most popular character. The first two Spider-Man movies were financial and critical successes. The third movie was the highest grossing movie that year. They were forced into a reboot after that. While the first Amazing Spider-Man simply wasn't very good, the second in 2014 was marred by its over-eagerness to expand itself into a MCU-style shared universe. Eventually, Sony made an agreement that put Spider-Man in the MCU. That left them with figuring out what to do with the Spider-Man rights without Spider-Man. That's like making an Indiana Jones movie without Indiana Jones. They are trying out an animated route later this year with Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse, but the big play was giving their most popular villain in the 90s the anti-hero treatment. Thus, we have Venom.

In the movie, the story of Venom is familiar enough to those who know about him from the comics and the 90s animated series. Eddie Brock (Tom Hardy) is a headstrong reporter. After an interview with famous billionaire tech titan Carlton Drake (Riz Ahmed) goes wrong, he winds up getting himself fired and dumped by his finance, Anne (Michelle Williams). He goes on a self-destructive tear for a while that leads him to investigating some shady practises by Drake's company concerning alien life forms called symbiotes that fuse with human hosts. Eddie ends up with a symbiote called Venom that Drake is desperate to get back.

There's a lot wrong with Venom, and I'll get to that shortly. I'd like to start with the good things though. This cast is far better than the movie deserves. Tom Hardy previously played Bane in The Dark Knight Rises, but Eddie Brock is much more of a character. We can understand what he's saying too. I love seeing Michelle Williams in a superhero movie. She is one of my favorite actresses and I like seeing her in something fun. Riz Ahmed has a great time hamming it up as the main villain. Jenny Slate and Reid Scott have supporting roles that they know how to play as well. No one in the cast elevates the movie. They play to the level of the script, and that works.

It's almost bizarre how much Venom is a high-class version of Upgrade. The computer chip in Logan Marshall-Green in Upgrade works very much like Venom when it's fused with Tom Hardy. Both the chip and the symbiote speak telepathically with their host and take over his body to perform acts with inhumane precision and control. A lot of the humor in both movies is generated from the leads looking panicked as they pull off unbelievable feats or with the inner dialogue with their "partner". It's even appropriate that Upgrade stars Logan Marshall-Green, who I've often described as an off-brand Tom Hardy. I didn't care for Upgrade. It didn't deliver enough on the premise (among many other problems). Venom does all the same stuff as Upgrade, but with a massive budget. There's a car chase through downtown San Francisco that beats anything in Upgrade simply because of the resources available.

Venom has some massive tonal issues. A lot of people die, most of them pretty horribly. Sometimes this is treated as a tragedy. Other times it's just a way to show off symbiote powers. The rest of the time, it's played for jokes. Eddie is outright a good guy, so that means all the bad stuff is supposed to be Venom's doing. But then the movie tries to make Venom a noble character too. There's no moral accountability in the movie, but it doesn't dip in black humor enough to forgive that. This movie would be much happier with an R-rated cut.

Individual beats of the story don't make much sense. The way Eddie gets fired in the first place doesn't make much sense. If he's the kind of guy who would do something that stupid, then there's no way he would've kept his job as long as he did. He's a character I don't believe existed before the movie began. Drake's motivation is pretty shaky as well. The movie literally makes a joke about what's driving Venom's decisions. We don't get to see enough chemistry between Eddie and Anne to really believe that she would continue to help him. It's a mess. There's a difference between a hero's origin story and a villain's origin story. Venom's backstory is a villain's backstory. There isn't much too it. The strategy in Venom is to fill in the blanks by mirroring Spider-Man's story. The result is disjointed.

Oh, and while I liked some of the early action sequences with Venom amplifying Eddie's abilities, the fight in the finale is awful. It's ugly and hard to follow. It was just a jumble of poorly lit CG animation. Really any time the movie tries to show us that it's Eddie beneath the suit looks bad.

I'll be honest. I went into Venom expecting the worst, and while it was far from perfect, I liked it. It zips along at a decent pace. It keeps a good sense of humor. It has actors I like playing simple characters. I found the movie most enjoyable when I treated it like it was a generic SciFi action movie rather than a Marvel movie. It's generic enough to work either way. The biggest stumbles were in the origin, so I'd invite a sequel with open arms, especially after what they tease in the mid-credits sequence.

Movie Theater LVPs: This was the weirdest movie theater crowd I've had in a while. Directly next to me, there was a dad who brought a 3 year old kid to see this. That was a poor calculation on the father's part. 10 minutes in, the child was repeating that he wanted to go home. The dad kept him pretty quiet otherwise though, so I didn't really care. There was a mom a couple rows in front of me who was not having as much luck. All I could hear was occasional bursts of her telling her kid to be quiet. The kid in front of me was an oddball. He kept leaning over to inspect the lights on the floor and periodically stuck his limbs out like he was contemplating doing something then reconsidering. And no one in the theater knew how to modulate their sound. No one whispered or even lowered their voice. They all spoke at normal volume. I don't know what was wrong with the people at that 1:30 Sunday showing. They didn't ruin the movie for me. They just confused me.

Verdict (?): Weakly Recommend

No comments:

Post a Comment