It’s good to be back. I
scaled things back last year, but I’m ready to resume my tradition of overly
in-depth Oscar predictions for each category. The guilds, BAFTAs, critics, and
supposedly Golden Globes have all made their picks. Now it’s my turn to figure
out what it all means with my multi-part-Oscar predictions.
I'm going to go
through each of the Oscar categories, tell you what has been nominated and won
elsewhere, and order the nominees from who I think is most to least likely to
win on Oscar night. That doesn't mean I'll be right, but it does mean I'll be
informed. Wish me luck.
Previously:
Introduction & International Feature
Original Song & Score
Costume Design & Makeup and Hairstyling
Supporting Actor & Actress
Lead Actor & Actress
Sound & Visual Effects
Director & Film Editing
Original & Adapted Screenplay
Best Picture
Glossary
Annie - Awards
for Animation
Eddie
- American Cinema Editors Award
PGA - Producers
Guild of America Award
BAFTA - British
Academy of Film and Television Arts Awards
Golden Globe -
Presented by the Hollywood Foreign Press Association Award
DGA -
Director's Guild of America
Best
Animated Feature
(In
Order of Likelihood)
Encanto
Annie -
Animated Feature - Nominee
PGA - Animated
Feature - Winner
BAFTA -
Animated Feature - Winner
Golden Globe -
Animated Feature - Winner
Eddie - Edited
Animated Feature – Winner
The
Mitchells vs. the Machines
Annie -
Animated Feature - Winner
PGA - Animated
Feature - Nominee
BAFTA -
Animated Feature - Nominee
Eddie - Edited
Animated Feature – Nominee
Flee
BAFTA -
Animated Feature - Nominee
Golden Globe -
Animated Feature - Nominee
Luca
Annie - Animated
Feature - Nominee
PGA - Animated
Feature - Nominee
BAFTA -
Animated Feature - Nominee
Golden Globe -
Animated Feature - Nominee
Raya
and the Last Dragon
Annie -
Animated Feature - Nominee
PGA - Animated
Feature - Nominee
Golden Globe - Animated
Feature - Nominee
Eddie - Edited
Animated Feature – Nominee
Every
year there’s a “Disney Spoiler” that a lot of people who think about this stuff
too long talk themselves into believing can win it. Wolkwalkers (2020). Klaus
(2019). Kubo and the Two Strings (2016). Anomalisa (2015). The
LEGO Movie (2014). The Wind Rises (2013). Paranorman (2012).
The only time it has worked in the last 10+ years was Spider-Man: Into the
Spider-Verse (2018). And for Spider-Verse to do it, it had to win
every single precursor award that season. For that reason, I don’t take The
Mitchells vs. the Machines seriously. The only reason to worry about Encanto’s
chances at all is because Disney has three nominees in the field. The only
other time that happened was 2012, when Brave managed to win despite Frankenweenie
and Wreck-It Ralph hanging around. Also, no film has ever won 4 of the
precursor awards and failed to win the Oscar. They are 9/9.
As
I’ve said or will say two other times, I’m afraid Flee’s trio of
nominations will do it more harm than good. Of its three nominations, this is
the one I’m most OK with it not standing a real chance in. The animation is a
necessary feature of the film, but it’s not the greatest animation you’re going
to find. It’s a doc first and animated second. It’s not winning, no matter how
cool a win would be. I don’t have to say much about Luca or Raya.
Everyone has agreed on Encanto being the supported Disney film.
Best
Documentary Feature
(In
Order of Likelihood)
Summer
of Soul
Eddie - Edited Documentary Feature - Winner
DGA - Directed Documentary – Nominee
PGA
-Documentary Feature - Winner
BAFTA -
Documentary Feature – Winner
Flee
Eddie - Edited
Documentary Feature - Nominee
PGA -Documentary Feature - Nominee
BAFTA - Documentary
Feature – Nominee
Attica
DGA - Directed
Documentary – Winner
Ascension
DGA - Directed
Documentary – Nominee
PGA
-Documentary Feature - Nominee
Writing
with Fire
PGA
-Documentary Feature - Nominee
I
could point to the fact the no doc has won 3 of the 4 main precursor awards and
lost the Oscar. It’s 6/6 since 2009*. However, with Documentary Feature, it’s
better to pick by feel. To get Oscar voters to watch a documentary, they need
to feel something. That’s why music docs do so well (Amy – 2015, Twenty
Feet From Stardom – 2013, Searching for Sugarman – 2012). If not
that, when they can recognize something from the news, that’s a plus (American
Factory – 2019, Icarus – 2017, OJ: Made in America – 2016, Citizenfour
– 2014). The latest exceptions are My Octopus Teacher (2020) and Free
Solo (2018). Both of those were crowdpleasers. Summer of Soul is the
best combination of all these things this year. It addresses race while also
being a lot of fun with the concert footage. It’s a crowdpleaser that makes you
think, which is a weapon in the Documentary Feature category.
*The
BAFTA award has only been around since 2011 and the PGA since 2007. The
precursor history isn’t all that rich here.
Flee is a paper tiger, I’m
afraid. Not because it’s bad. In fact, it’s one of my favorite movies of the
year. What I mean is that the absolutely unique triple nomination looks
formidable. However, it splits the vote. Some will want it to win in Animated
Feature to take down Disney. Others will want to award it in International
Feature since the other big nominees there have other major nods. And there are
other directions to go in Documentary Feature. Support hasn’t coalesced around
any one nomination for Flee, sadly. Documentary is its best chance, I’d
say. Summer of Soul is a much easier movie though. Attica is too
much of a bummer. Ascension is a little too esoteric from my
understanding. Writing With Fire I really liked but it’s a little dull
and has the language barrier.